Who Verifies the Certificates? Nigeria’s Recurring Crisis of Credentials and Accountability

On 3 October 2026, PREMIUM TIMES reported that it could find no evidence that any recognised academic institution had awarded Anthony Kila the rank of professor. Mr Kila, a familiar face on national television and, since August 2025, pro-chancellor of Michael and Cecilia Ibru University, rejected the finding and said he stands by his title and the credentials behind it. Within days, the university asked him to step aside pending an investigation, the ICPC was reported to have set up a team to examine the matter, and ARISE News announced that he would no longer appear on its platforms.

Whatever the final outcome of Mr Kila’s case, it returns us to a question Nigeria has failed to answer for more than a quarter of a century: who verifies the certificates of the people we entrust with public office, professional responsibility and the education of our children?

From Salisu Buhari’s fall as Speaker of the House of Representatives in 1999 to the arraignment of a former federal minister in July 2026, the country has moved from one credential scandal to the next. Some cases end in conviction; others remain allegations or unresolved proceedings. But one pattern holds. In case after case, the doubts surfaced only after the person had already secured the office, the job or the title.

The question is not academic. INEC has put on public display the particulars and credentials submitted by candidates for the 2027 presidential election, and at least one legal challenge to a candidate’s certificate has already been filed. Once again, the country is preparing to test credentials in court rather than at the point where they are submitted.

A certificate is meant to be evidence of achievement. In Nigeria it too often works as a key: to public office, to promotion, to salary and to social standing. When the key is counterfeit, the cost falls on those who competed honestly for the same opportunity, on the institutions that relied on the document, and on citizens who expected the competence they were promised.

A Quarter-Century of Scandals

Salisu Buhari’s case remains the template. Weeks after his election as Speaker in 1999, he was found to have misrepresented his age, which placed him below the constitutional minimum for membership of the House, and to have claimed a University of Toronto degree he did not hold. He resigned, was convicted and sentenced to two years in prison with the option of a fine, paid the fine, and was later pardoned by President Olusegun Obasanjo. In 2013, he was appointed to the Governing Council of the University of Nigeria, Nsukka.

That last detail deserves to be read slowly. A man who left the Speakership over a false degree claim later helped govern one of the country’s foremost universities. If our institutions could not draw a line there, it is hardly surprising that questions about academic titles and university governance are with us again.

Okoi Ofem Obono-Obla, a former presidential aide, was arraigned by the ICPC over a GCE English Literature result allegedly used to gain admission to study law at the University of Jos. The available reports establish that he was charged; I have not established the final outcome.

Kemi Adeosun resigned as Minister of Finance in 2018 after her NYSC exemption certificate was acknowledged not to be genuine. The ICPC later stopped its investigation, and nothing in the record establishes that she knowingly forged the document. Her case illustrates a distinction that runs through this whole discussion: proving that a document is false is not the same as proving that its holder committed a crime.

Uche Nnaji, former Minister of Innovation, Science and Technology, resigned in October 2025 after a PREMIUM TIMES investigation questioned his claimed University of Nigeria, Nsukka degree and his NYSC certificate. In July 2026, the ICPC arraigned him before the Federal High Court in Abuja on six counts, including forgery of both documents, receiving about ₦29.5 million in salaries and allowances under false pretences, and money laundering. The commission alleges that both the university and the NYSC disowned the certificates. Mr Nnaji pleaded not guilty and was granted bail. In the meantime, he had won his party’s governorship primary in Enugu State. The charges remain allegations until the court decides. But that a man who left the federal cabinet under such a cloud could secure a governorship ticket months later says a great deal about how little the question of credentials weighs in our politics.

These cases differ in their evidence and their legal outcomes, and they should not be lumped together. Together, however, they point to the same institutional gap: qualifications were accepted first and questioned later.

When Academic Titles Become a Public Concern

The Kila controversy carries the problem from public office into the academy itself.

Mr Kila has said his professorship was awarded in 2016 by the European Centre for Advanced and Professional Studies, which he described as based in Cambridge. PREMIUM TIMES has since published a further report questioning his degrees, from bachelor’s to doctorate. He disputes the findings, and the investigations are continuing.

Academic titles carry authority because the public assumes they represent recognised achievement. When someone speaks as “Professor” on television, in policy debate or at the head of a university council, listeners reasonably assume that an established academic process stands behind the title. That assumption is exactly what makes verification essential.

A pro-chancellor is not a lecturer, and the qualifications required to chair a governing council differ from those required to teach. But a council chairman’s claimed academic standing shapes how a university presents itself to students, parents and regulators. The central institutional question in this case is a simple one: did the university independently confirm the title before it appointed him and published it on its website? Universities should not rely on biographies supplied by candidates, or on titles that have merely been repeated in the media for years.

The Tinubu Diploma: Precision in Both Directions

No account of Nigeria’s certificate controversies would be complete without the dispute over President Bola Tinubu’s Chicago State University diploma. It deserves careful treatment, because it is the case in which political loyalty has most distorted public understanding of the evidence.

In 2023, Atiku Abubakar sought Tinubu’s academic records from Chicago State University through a United States court, alleging that the diploma submitted to INEC had been forged. The university confirmed that Tinubu attended and graduated in 1979, explained that it did not keep a copy of the original diploma, and showed that replacement diplomas had been issued at different times. Discrepancies in other records, including dates of birth, fuelled wide public debate.

The BBC’s Global Disinformation Team examined the documents and found no evidence that the diploma Tinubu submitted to INEC was forged; it matched the copy given to the commission and resembled the university’s replacement diplomas. In October 2023, the Supreme Court upheld Tinubu’s election, declining to admit the new evidence because it had not been raised in the original petition in the manner the law requires.

That ruling was procedural. It was not a criminal trial that determined whether the diploma was forged, and it should not be presented as one. Equally, the fact that the election was upheld does not settle the broader question. If a presidential candidate’s academic records could become the subject of foreign court proceedings only after an election, something was missing from the process before it. The same pattern is repeating ahead of 2027: Atiku and the ADC have filed a suit questioning the NYSC certificate the President submitted for the coming election, and the court has yet to rule.

The standard must be the same for everyone, supporter or opponent. Where a qualification is required for public office, the public deserves to know what was alleged, what the awarding institution confirmed and what the courts decided, and to hear it before the votes are cast.

When the Fraud Was Proven

Some cases have ended in convictions, and they show what credential fraud is really for.

Muhammad Said Musa, a former official of the Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission, was convicted over forged academic and NYSC certificates used to obtain employment. Under a plea bargain, according to the ICPC, he refunded about ₦36.59 million. Abdulwahab Sule, a former National Examinations Council employee, was convicted over a forged diploma attributed to the former Federal University of Technology, Yola, and sentenced on three counts to terms running concurrently, an effective 12 years. Hassan Abdullahi, a superintendent in the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps, was convicted over a forged Nigeria Certificate in Education used to secure promotion, and ordered to refund the benefits.

The economics are plain. A false qualification can secure a job, speed up a promotion and draw a salary for years. In Musa’s case, the refund alone ran to tens of millions of naira. Each conviction should therefore trigger a harder question for the employer: how did the document pass through recruitment or promotion, was the awarding institution ever contacted, and how many years passed before anyone checked?

Other cases show why reporting on this subject must be exact. The ICPC announced the arrest in 2021 of two Federal Road Safety Corps officials over allegedly forged University of Abuja degrees, and arraigned a deputy director at the NIPC, Yusuf Abubakar Mustapha, who pleaded not guilty; I have not established final outcomes in either case. The case of Christian Abah, a former member of the House of Representatives, shows how far one dispute can travel: a Federal High Court ruled against him in 2015 over a purported diploma from the Federal Polytechnic, Mubi, the Court of Appeal set that ruling aside, and the Supreme Court restored it in March 2017.

An arrest is not a conviction. A charge is not proof of guilt. A first judgment may not be the last. These distinctions do not weaken the case for accountability. They are what make it credible.

A Recollection from the University of Jos

My concern with this subject is not drawn only from political controversies.

Around 1982/83, when I was a student in the Department of Linguistics at the University of Jos, I recall the university conducting a screening exercise covering students and lecturers across faculties. As I remember it, the exercise exposed cases of allegedly forged credentials among both groups, and one of the lecturers who taught us French and German was among those whose qualifications came under scrutiny. I have often wondered since whether those doubts help to explain the difficulties some of us had in his classes.

This is a personal recollection. I have not found independent documentary evidence of the exercise or of that lecturer’s circumstances, and I offer it as memory, not as established fact.

But it left me with a question that has never gone away: what happens to students when the qualifications of the people teaching them have never been properly verified? Students spend years attending classes, paying fees and preparing for examinations on the assumption that their teachers possess the knowledge their positions imply. A student may never discover why the instruction was poor. The institution that hired the lecturer is the only party in a position to know, and it is the institution’s duty to find out before the first lecture, not after a scandal.

What Has to Change

Scandals that recur across politics, the civil service, security agencies and universities are not a series of accidents. They are the predictable output of a system that accepts credentials on trust and checks them only under pressure, when a journalist raises an alarm, a rival goes to court, or a controversy becomes inconvenient for someone with influence. Five changes would go a long way.

Verify at source, before appointment. Where a qualification is material to an appointment, election or promotion, the body relying on it should confirm it directly with the institution that awarded it, and keep a written record of the response. A photocopy, an affidavit or a self-written biography is not verification.

Close the gap in candidate screening. INEC publishes the documents candidates submit, but testing them is left largely to rivals and citizens who must go to court, often against tight deadlines and while the campaign rolls on. Confirmation with the issuing institutions should happen before a name appears on the ballot, not after.

Build a secure national verification system. WAEC and NECO already offer result verification, and the NYSC can confirm its own certificates. Universities and polytechnics should be brought into one secure system, compliant with the Nigeria Data Protection Act, through which authorised employers can confirm a qualification with the institution that awarded it.

Audit the payroll, not just new hires. The convictions above show that a false certificate can go undetected for years. Periodic verification audits across the public service, especially at promotion points, would catch what recruitment missed.

Report outcomes, not just arrests. Anti-corruption agencies announce arrests and arraignments readily. They should be just as consistent in reporting convictions, acquittals, withdrawn charges and investigations closed for lack of evidence. A public that only ever hears the accusation cannot judge whether the system works.

Verification must also be fair. A misspelt name, a wrong date or a missing file is not automatically proof of fraud; older records contain clerical errors, and institutions may need time to retrieve archives. A proper process separates administrative mistakes from deliberate falsification and gives the person concerned a chance to respond. None of this requires a public blacklist built on allegations. It requires routine, documented checks applied to everyone.

Education Is Not a Certificate

A persistent perception in Nigerian public life is that the consequences of misconduct depend on the status of the person involved. A junior officer may be dismissed or jailed over a forged certificate, while a controversy involving a senior figure can run for years, or end in a pardon and a fresh appointment, without any clear public reckoning. Political connections should not shield anyone, and public attention alone should not condemn anyone. Accountability and fairness are not opposing principles. Both rest on evidence.

Nigeria also needs to recover a simple distinction: education is not the same thing as a certificate. A certificate records an achievement. It does not create the knowledge, discipline or competence the achievement is supposed to represent. When someone uses a false qualification to obtain a position, the wrong is not confined to the paper. It is done to the candidate who was passed over, to the institution that was deceived and to the public that now depends on competence that may not exist.

The questions are always the same. Who verified the certificate? Who benefited from it? What checks were carried out before the appointment? What happened when doubts emerged? And what followed when wrongdoing was established?

These questions belong in the routine administration of every public institution, asked before the appointment is made, not after the scandal breaks. With a general election approaching and candidates’ credentials already before the public, there has rarely been a better time to start asking them.

A certificate is a claim to knowledge or achievement. It should never be allowed to substitute for either.


Okoye Sunday is a researcher and writer.

Leave a Comment

Shopping Cart